As a seasoned tattoo artist, I cherish discussing inks and techniques. However, I’m concerned when I hear about people using questionable ink alternatives for DIY tattoos. I’ve heard some wild stories, from pen ink to food coloring. While the ingenuity is appreciated, it’s often unsafe and ill-advised.

Stick and Poke Tattoo
@cora.poke Via Instagram – Want your tattoo to look brighter? Try tattoo balm 

Stick and poke tattoos are a minimalist and trendy option. However, the same ink safety rules apply. Let’s explore the do’s and don’ts of alternative inks for these tattoos. We’ll examine the science behind different inks and their potential skin effects. Discover why professionals, like myself, prefer using tested and reliable inks.

Stick and Poke Tattoo
@corrieforeman Via Instagram – Want your tattoo to look brighter? Try tattoo balm 

Let’s be clear: I’m not here to spoil anyone’s fun. My goal is to ensure we’re all informed when it comes to DIY tattoos. Knowledge, like tattoos, is permanent! So, let’s explore stick and poke ink alternatives and reveal the facts. Stay informed, because the more you know, the better your tattoos will be.

Stick and Poke Tattoos

Hello tattoo lovers! Tori, your trusted tattoo expert, is back to explore the latest trends. Today, we’re diving into the free-spirited world of stick and poke tattoos. We’ll also discuss why using alternative inks can be a risky decision.

Stick and Poke Tattoo
@cora.poke Via Instagram – Want your tattoo to look brighter? Try tattoo balm 

Back when I began my tattoo journey, stick and poke tattoos were incredibly popular. Artists and enthusiasts loved their unique, handcrafted appeal. These machine-free tattoos could be stunning art or simple designs, depending on the artist’s skill. Their distinctive look adds character. But today, let’s focus on the ink itself – the vital element of these body art pieces.

An Inkling About Ink Alternatives for Stick and Pokes

Before we explore ink options, a word of caution: I strongly advise against using alternative inks for stick and poke tattoos. I’ve witnessed the results of homemade inks, and they’re often problematic. While saving money might seem appealing, consider the risks. Skin irritation, tissue damage, and infections are potential consequences. Let’s examine some popular alternatives that appear tempting but are ultimately not worth the risk.

India Ink

Stick and Poke
@Allef Vinicius Via Unsplash – Want your tattoo to look brighter? Try tattoo balm 

India ink is often seen as a cheap and accessible option. Plus, it’s non-toxic. However, it’s not ideal for lasting tattoos. A friend learned this the hard way. Her sunflower tattoo, done with India ink, faded fast. It quickly resembled a wilted daisy. India ink fades quickly. This can make your first stick and poke experience unpredictable.

Pen Ink

In 2025, the DIY tattoo trend using pen ink persists, but it’s a risky gamble. Think of it as using tape to repair plumbing. Pen ink is designed for paper, not skin. It’s unsterile, raising the risk of infections. Choosing this method is like inviting trouble. Injecting pen ink can severely damage your skin tissue.

Sharpie Ink

Remember drawing temporary tattoos with Sharpies as kids? That’s not the best approach for real body art. Sharpie ink fades fast and looks unprofessional. More importantly, it can be toxic if it gets into your skin. Stick to using Sharpies on paper instead.

Stick and Poke
@Jonathan Cooper Via Unsplash – Want your tattoo to look brighter? Try tattoo balm 

Pencil Graphite

Surprisingly, pencil graphite has emerged as an unconventional option. However, be warned: graphite is not safe for your skin. It can lead to permanent damage. Once embedded, it’s nearly impossible to remove, even with laser treatments.

Food Coloring

Food coloring is commonly used for cake decorating. However, it’s absolutely unsuitable for tattoos. It blurs details and fades quickly. Furthermore, the safety of food coloring for eating is debated. Imagine the risks of injecting it into your skin!

Eyeliner

Stick and Poke
@Ilya Plakhuta Via Unsplash – Want your tattoo to look brighter? Try tattoo balm 

Finally, consider eyeliner. While safe for your eyelids, it’s unsuitable for larger skin tattoos. Your body will likely reject much of the ink during healing. This can result in a blurred and distorted tattoo design.

Conclusion

Our exploration of stick and poke tattoos concludes here. Remember, your skin is precious. While DIY tattoos seem tempting, the ink alternatives we discussed pose significant risks. Cheaper options can lead to serious health problems. As a seasoned tattoo artist in 2025, I strongly advise prioritizing your well-being over fleeting excitement.

Author

You know you're going to give your kid a complex if you call them "The Mean Bean" instead of; sweetiepie, sugar face, bear, etc. My nickname stuck- even when I got nicer. AND my affinity for all things BEAN happens to be tremendous; Coffee beans (my coffee feign), Cocoa beans, Vanilla beans, chickpeas (yes, it's a bean), black beans....and so on. As for the "mean" part, depends on which ex-boyfriend you ask. I think I'm super sugary. And no, I will not be writing any guides about beans. Unless I get a special request.

Write A Comment