Yoga vs. Pilates

  • by mswen
  • -
  • September 28, 2008
Rate Guide Rating_3_0 (2)
-621239228

It seems that whenever The Beautiful People (read: celebrities) are asked for their workout secrets, they spout one of two answers: yoga or Pilates. And, judging by the fact that they need to look fabulous for a living, I put a lot of stock into their answers. The question is, with both fitness programs being super-popular among the fit set, which one is better? IS one better than the other? The answer is no. They both have the ability to produce amazing results, so what really matters is the one that's right for you. Let's take a look at what each practice entails.

Yoga

Yoga originated in India and is meant to not only be a physical form of exercise, but spritual as well — it’s about creating balance in the body by developing both strength and flexibility.

A typical yoga routine has the student perform a series of poses on a mat.  Each pose has specific physical benefits, and uses the body’s own weight for resistance.  In addition, yoga classes may also include instruction on breathing, chanting, or meditation, depending on the individual teacher and the type of yoga in which he or she has trained.  There are six different styles, all unique in emphasis so that you can choose the one that’s right for you.

Case study: Madonna

Widget_bx-kthsgzpr7jvpnd14n4n

Madonna practices the Ashtanga system of yoga, which is a vigorous, athletic style of yoga.

Exhale

28 arlington street Boston, MA 02116

This Best of Boston winner is beloved for not only its top-notch instructors, but for it’s gorgeous and ultra-zen yoga studio.

This studio specializes in hot yoga — classes performed in an over 90 degree room.

This studio specializes in hot yoga — classes performed in an over 90 degree room.

Back Bay Yoga Studio

112 Boylston Street Boston, MA 02116

This no-frills studio caters to both beginners and advanced students.

Karma Yoga Studio

1132 Massachusetts Ave, Cambridge, MA 02138

A great variety of classes and experienced instructors make this studio a local favorite.

A great variety of classes and experienced instructors make this studio a local favorite.

Sadhana Yoga Studios

15 Worcester St Boston, MA 02118

Heated yoga in a small space and with small classes might not sound desirable, but this studio always gets super duper rave reviews for its instructors.

South Boston Yoga

141 Dorchester Ave Boston, MA 02127

Large-ish classes might be intimidating, but the instructors make sure to cater to both beginners and the more advanced.

This video shows a demonstration of the Ashtanga yoga method.

At home options

Since all you need is a mat, yoga is one of the easiest workouts you can do outside of a gym.  Just make sure you have a DVD player, because yoga is instructor-dependent. 

There are countless yoga DVD’s out there, so my advice is to scour Amazon and check out the bestsellers and read the user reviews.  Because there are so many different types of yoga, newbies should even check out their local library or Netflix to avoid buying something that may not end up being for them.  And, it’s always best to start out with a beginner video first.   

Widget_au78dv7fpgjiudknzwyppy

For either yoga or Pilates, invest in a nice, thick yoga mat.

Widget_ceqqgdgoveir3qjbrwmdv0

Instructor Rodney Yee wins high marks for being down-to-earth (read: no New Age gobbedlygook) and excellent with his cuing. In this DVD, he will guide you through a tough, intermediate workout.

Yoga and Pilates in Boston

 

Pilates

Pilates, created in the early 20th century by Joseph Pilates, focuses on the core postural muscles which help keep the body balanced.  Each workout emphasizes mind over matter, breathing, control, centering, concentration, precision, and flow.

The Pilates method emphasizes quality over quantity, and so exercises are done precisely and slowly rather than in many repetitions.  Exercises are done on a mat, or on a piece of equipment called a Reformer, which utilizes the student’s own body weight for resistance.

Pilates devotees say that they have become stronger, longer, leaner, and more graceful after incorporating Pilates into their fitness routine. 

Case study: Hilary Duff

Widget_cvscvvyk5afpdpexl41gqq

Really, in Hollywood, who DOESN’T do Pilates? And in Hilary Duff’s case, adding Pilates into her exercise routine helped her get lean.

A great place for either private instruction with complete attention to your every move, or reformer classes.

A great place for either private instruction with complete attention to your every move, or reformer classes.

Studio Elle Pilates

1318 Beacon Street Brookline, MA 02446

Enthusiastic and devoted instructors will help you achieve your goals in a non-intimidating atmosphere.

This studio is tucked inside the Boston Athetic Club, making it convenient if you’d like to squeeze in a treadmill run afterwards.

This studio is tucked inside the Boston Athetic Club, making it convenient if you’d like to squeeze in a treadmill run afterwards.

Body Center the

1 Holden St, Brookline, MA 02445

The class sizes in this Stott-practicing studio are limited to just three people, so even if you don’t take a private class, you’ll certainly feel like you are.

The class sizes in this Stott-practicing studio are limited to just three people, so even if you don’t take a private class, you’ll certainly feel like you are.

Boston BodyWorks Studios

38 Newbury Street Boston, MA 02114

This calm, cutting-edge studio also certifies future Pilates teachers…so they MUST be good.

Mind In Motion Pilates Studio

70B Union Street Medford, MA 02155

This classic Pilates studio specializes in small classes and ultra-personalized one-on-one instruction.

This video clip show some basic Pilates moves for abs.

At home options

Many Pilates moves and routines can be done via mat work on the floor (making following a DVD an easy at-home alternative), using resistance accessories to add more of a challenge to your workout.  To get the full benefits of Pilates, like you would if you were taking instructor-led lessons, you will need to invest in a serious piece of equipment called a Reformer.

Tip: if you’re looking to save money, do your mat work via DVD at home, and take classes if you’re looking to take it up a notch using the Reformer.

Widget_ce6do9gxxa5yofgwgzzejr

Stott Pilates was created in the traditional way Joseph Pilates intended, yet modified taking into account modern thought and research.

Widget_cgykljq7nllzt3s1i5qmu3

These resistance bands, from Stott Pilates, add upper and lower body resistance to matwork and simulate many of the moves performed on a reformer.

Widget_dmxjdmcydeskley0zpgu6y

This Allegra Reformer will set you back over $2,000, but if you’ve got the room (and the cash), it’s a great piece of equipment and may just pay for itself when you no longer have to shell out cash for a studio membership. It even folds down flat for storage.

Share on StumbleUpon Share on Facebook Tweet this Guide! Share on Digg Share on Reddit Add to del.icio.us

Discussions

Default_author_xsmall

I always do yoga because yoga increases strength by toning the muscles if people do this correctly. -—————————————————————- Moury roberts < a href =http://www.trainwithmeonline.com/programs.asp "dofollow">Workout Routine

-621924948

I like to say I do yoga just so I have an excuse to go to lulu lemon and spend $100 on a pair of butt-happy spandex.

-621293768

I am a devoted Pilates fan and prefer it 84943 times more than yoga! And yay to Studio Elle, my instructor at my gym owns it. She’s awesome!