True Blood vs. Twilight:

Rate Guide Rating_4_5 (3)
3456289629340

Between True Blood, Twilight and The Vampire Diaries, our lives are being taken over by the undead. Maybe you're a fan of sparkles or teenage angst. Maybe you're a fan of HBO. Whatever the case may be, there can only be one...Highlander. Wait...what? So fangbangers, do you prefer one over the other and if so, why? Maybe it's an actor who tickles your fancy or maybe you just really like men who sparkle. Whatever the reason I want to know what it is about these vampires that keep you hooked!

The Cast

When comparing acting, plot and overall quality, I think True Blood wins, hands down. But if you’re going to compare the cast, well that’s tough. Let’s just say that the people in Bon Temps and Forks are very easy on the eyes.

The Men of True Blood

Widget_ahs_zcnlxm34498iwmb9lm

Bill Compton died shortly after the Civil War. He is trying to mainstream with humans and lives off of synthetic blood, True Blood.

Sam Merlotte is Sookie’s boss, a secret admirer as well as a shifter a.k.a. he turns into a dog.

Eric Northman is the Sheriff of Area 5. He is the oldest vampire in Louisiana and was once a Viking. He has a soft spot for money, blood and Sookie.

Jason Stakhouse – He’s tough to sum up. Jason in the books and Jason in the show are two different guys right now. Whichever way you’re going, just know that he looks great with his shirt off.

The Boys of Twilight

Widget_b7jtk0cj5d1i9rbgtqqila

Edward Cullen – Vampire. Vegetarian. Sparkles. He believes he is a monster and often spends his time listening to music, brooding, chasing animals, pouting and reading the minds of everyone around him.

Jacob Black is a good guy. He fixes up trucks, teaches Bella how to ride a motorcycle and oh yeah, he’s also a werewolf. He doesn’t approve of Bella seeing Edward, a bloodsucker, so he tries to woo her in New Moon.

Leading Ladies

Both True Blood and Twilight have beautiful leading ladies. You think vampires would fight over anyone less than gorgeous?

Sookie Stackhouse

Widget_bpq5rbblrjhbz_fvqviryq

Sookie Stackhouse is a Louisiana girl at heart. She’s sweet, smart and sexy, but she’s a little odd. Sookie is a telepath, meaning she can read people’s minds and hear their thoughts – much like Edward in Twilight. She’s open to the idea that vampires, werewolves, witches, fairies and magic exists, but often finds herself in a lot of trouble. She’s independent and can take of herself.

Bella Swan

Widget_bd1btxje1kclvjwphmjcsi

Bella Swan is a teenager from Arizona. She moves to Forks, Washington to live with her father. She’s shy, clumsy and a bit awkward. No special power here. She’s a tad on the needy side as well. When compared to Sookie, while Bella might have that effortless girl-next-door look, I think Sookie would win in a fight.

He Sparkles

Widget_dax0h_obtp47fucodcd5fq

This vampire can go out in the sun, but he chooses not to or else he’ll reveal what he is: a monster…that sparkles. Yep. He sparkles. Ooooo scary.

He Burns

Widget_c-ekxlm1xmt6wa9kwzwxgm

This vampire can’t go out in the sun or he will burn. Bill, in an effort to save Sookie, went out in the sunlight to protect her from a serial killer. (I didn’t ruin anything – there wouldn’t be a season 2 if Bill died…again.)

The Relationships

It must be hard dating a vampire. They either won’t have sex for fear of killing you or they will, but only if they can bite you during it. Do you tell her you’re a vampire or let her figure it out for herself? Whatever the story, it seems like vampire/human relationships are this year’s TV trend.

Bill & Sookie

Widget_d76rlwqu9bw7usodllrpl7

Sookie, a Louisiana waitress, and Bill, a Civil War vet/vampire, meet in a bar where Sookie works. Sookie, who is also a telepath, realizes that she can’t read Bill’s mind and immediately feels smitten. The two have their ups and downs, but I can’t say much else without ruining the books/show for anyone.

Edward & Bella

Widget_bveambq-zhik7tomtm_cq7

Bella, a clumsy teen, and Edward, a brooding vampire, meet in school and instantly have a connection. She’s intrigued because he’s different and he’s interested because he can’t read her mind. Edward tries to stay away from her because her blood is so exotic to him that he’s convinced he’ll kill her. Finally he can’t hold back any longer and the two fall in love after what seems like three days.

The Good Stuff

Oh come on. Don’t pretend like you didn’t want to know.

They wait until page 144

Widget_cswzwkrapbejw9sp_poweh

Bill and Sookie are grown-ups – no teenage brooding here. They don’t try to ignore the sexual tension and go at it in book one.

They wait until book #3

Widget_bbskbirztaqr3t1ccxgtcn

Edward is concerned about killing humans due to his incredible strength. Sex is off limits. It takes until book 3, Eclipse, for these love birds to do the deed and let me tell you that was a LONG wait!

The "Other" Guy

Well of course these aren’t happily ever after relationships. What fun would it be if there wasn’t another extremely attractive guy in the picture?

Who will Sookie choose: Bill or Eric?

Widget_dpiy7bbcreokn61tcmq6gm

I won’t spoil it for those who haven’t finished the books, but obviously both Eric and Bill want Sookie. It’s no surprise that Sookie wants both of them. Season 2 deviates from the original story a bit, so I wonder if the hookups in the book will take place in the show.

Who would I choose? I’ve been an Eric fan since he first popped up. After seeing him as Mr. January I’m convinced that Eric wins. Edward who?

Who will Bella choose: Edward or Jacob?

Widget_bruki8ierky58ru650waop

If you’ve finished the Twilight series, then you know who she chooses. I highly doubt the movies will change that. It is fun to imagine the end differently though! Like Sookie, she is involved with both a vampire and werewolf. Unlike Sookie, she doesn’t sleep with both of them.

Who would I choose? That’s tough. I was team Edward for a long time, but after seeing this trailer including Bella & Jacob (warning: there are teenage girls screaming) I’m starting to rethink my loyalty.

The Books

Widget_dqywvjib5lipyghk32awxb

You can read four Twilight books or eight (one is missing) Sookie Stackhouse books. Choose wisely. (Side note: Harris’ series is far from over. The next book in Sookie’s series will be out on Oct. 6 and I think 2-3 more are on the way.)

Believe it or not, both series are quick reads. I prefer Charlaine Harris’ writing style over Stephanie Meyer’s, but to each their own.

So who wins?

I’m a big fan of True Blood. I don’t feel ashamed telling people that I watch it. It’s the grown-up version of Twilight, but with more nudity, swearing and outrageous characters. The books are short, easy reads and I don’t feel like I’m lugging around a brick in my bag. Sure the TV show deviates a bit from the books, but who knows what’s up their sleeves. I definitely recommend checking them both out.

Twilight is a fun movie; it’s not meant to be taken seriously. The directing was crappy, the acting was so-so and the sparkling…come on! Still, the 14-year-old inside of me is giddy beyond all reason. It’s a fun read, but I think that series takes a bit longer than Sookie Stackhouse – if only for the reason that I couldn’t read past chapter three in New Moon for like a month (I was NOT okay with the break-up.)

All in all – True Blood wins. Hot guys. Hot ladies. No angst. No emo. No sparkles.

The Fans

Where would either be without the fans?

Judah Friedlander's case for Twilight

Widget_dqsnhlzndmvk2gpfjgktkb

You know, the guy from 30 Rock. I read this quote in New York Magazine:

“Here’s my review of Twilight: Footlose is a better vampire movie than Twilight, and it’s not even a vampire movie. There’s not one set of fangs in Twilight. If you like chick flicks and you hate horror movies, it’s a great movie.”

added by aliciak 08/04/2009

Other Vampire Guides:

Share on StumbleUpon Share on Facebook Tweet this Guide! Share on Digg Share on Reddit Add to del.icio.us

Discussions

-618919168

I’m not familiar with either one of these…should I jump on Twilight-reading bandwagon?

-619992718

I’m a fangbanger all the way. I kid. I kid. I like both about the same … I think they are silly yet I still can’t stop!

3456292546980

Nerd.

About The Author

-619894088

freeandflawed Rss 

Chicago
Jennifer is a 20-something blogger from Chicago. She loves being challenged, which is why you can usually find her sharing her love for all things geek here at Guidespot, maintaining two of her own blogs & and organizing meetups for Chicago bloggers. As if that weren't enough, she is also the C...

Contributors To This Guide