Indianapolis' Best Martini 2007

by IndianapolisCitysearch  0 contributors  -  November 04, 2008   + Add To This Guide

-621895138

You voted for the best Martini in Indianapolis, and we counted. Check out the results below.

1. Oceanaire Seafood Room

30 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN

Swank setting for ocean-fresh seafood and shaken martinis.

Reviews:

  • “Oceanaire – Never a Bad Experience”
  • “hmm i dont know”
  • “As usual, good, service was slightly off”
  • “Food was not that good, and parking was impossible”
  • SPECTACULAR!!”

Tips: Use the valet parking service on the weekends, as many nearby parking garages quickly fill.

Oceanaire Seafood Room

2. St. Elmo Steak House

127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN

The steak is properly aged and the portions are substantial at the oldest steak house in the city.

Reviews:

  • EVERYTHING THAT GLITTERS ISN’T GOLD
  • “Well derserved ‘best of’ rating”
  • “One of the most OVER-RATED.”
  • “Go for the steak, eat the shrimp cocktail”
  • “Awesome Steaks”

Tips: St. Elmo has over 20,000 wine bottles in its cellar. Ask your server for the perfect match for your dinner.

St. Elmo Steak House

3. Sullivan's Steakhouse

3316 E 86TH St, Indianapolis, IN

Oversize cocktails and a classy club atmosphere make this an Indy steak house favorite.

Reviews:

  • ""
  • BEST AROUND
  • “Absolutely Fabulous”
  • “It’s so money, baby!”
  • “Best Steak House in the City”

Sullivan’s Steakhouse

4. Gelo Lounge

5252 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN

Sophisticated South Beach-style nightclub invades Indy’s northeast side.

Reviews:

  • “Club is closed”
  • “worst bar in indy”
  • “Great Place!”

Tips: Leave the jeans and T-shirt at home. You will feel much more comfortable in khakis and button-down shirts in this upscale club.

Gelo Lounge

5. Nicky Blaine's

7 N Meridian St Ste 100, Indianapolis, IN

Couples congregate and suits extend happy hour at this classy 1920’s-style martini bar.

Reviews:

  • “class”
  • “Nicky Blaine’s”
  • “Big Moves”
  • “Best Martinis, Great customer service, very busy place "
  • “Horrid service, rude treatement, would avoid it at all costs from now on”

Tips: Non-smokers congregate in the separate back room to avoid the heavy smell of cigar smell that radiates from the bar.

Nicky Blaine’s

6. Olives--A Martini Bar

40 Jackson Pl, Indianapolis, IN

Suits sip on martinis, while couples consume cocktails at this tony hotel bar.

Reviews:

  • “Great Service”
  • “Great Atmosphere”

Tips: Forget about valet, the Circle Centre Mall parking lot is just a block away and charges only $1 if you are parked for three hours or less.

Olives—A Martini Bar

 

Best Martini in Indianapolis

The Best Martini based on votes from Citysearch users.

7. Scholars Inn Gourmet Cafe

725 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN

Well-received eclectic menu featuring upscale service and casual prices.

Reviews:

  • “Wonderful Brunch”
  • “Ok dinner, bad service”
  • “Excellent sandwiches!”
  • “Brunch Has a few Kinks”
  • “Above Average Food, but Menu Tries too Hard”

Tips: Champagne cocktails are half-price during brunch on Sundays.

Scholars Inn Gourmet Cafe

8. The Melting Pot

5650 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN

It’s hip to dip at this cozy fondue-lover’s paradise.

Reviews:

  • “Ehh”
  • “Wonderful place for romantic or family atmosphere.”
  • ROMANTIC AND FUN!”
  • “Amazing!!!”
  • “Delightfully Different”

Tips: Prime-time reservations often require several weeks’ notice.

The Melting Pot

9. Blu Martini

4705 E 96th St Ste 47-49, Indianapolis, IN

Slide down sushi while sipping on specialty martinis in a sophisticated upscale setting.

Reviews:

  • “Not for Everyone”
  • “avoid”
  • “good drinks and surprisingly good sushi”
  • “First time out in a long time was terrific”

Tips: Blu Martini frequently features live Jazz on Wednesday nights, while DJ’s spin music on Friday and Saturday nights.

Blu Martini

10. Lulu's Restaurant & Cocktails

8487 Union Chapel Rd Suite 560, Indianapolis, IN

You’ll never hurt for dinner conversation between this lively spot’s wild decor, culinary concoctions and cocktails.

Reviews:

  • “Would Not Recommend”
  • “Not Impressed”
  • “Indianapolis Favorite”
  • “You have to try this!”
  • “Lovely at Lulu’s”

Tips: Have room for dessert? Try the chocolatini.

Lulu’s Restaurant & Cocktails

Powered by Citysearch

Share on StumbleUpon Share on Facebook Tweet this Guide! Share on Digg Share on Reddit Add to del.icio.us

Discussions