What to Look For
Before you start running around looking for a bike, you should give some thought to what you want in a commuter bike. Are you a practical person with a penchant for the bare necessities? Do you want great value or excellent quality? Or do you want your bike to also express how fun you are (or want to be)? This guide will show you all sides and help you decide what’s best for you.
Style vs. Comfort
Everyone likes a little style in their ride, and there’s plenty of style to be found. But you may find that you need to trade off the coolness of your ride with the practicality of getting to work safely and comfortably. If you have a short commute, then style may be higher on your list. But don’t discount the value of comfort if your commute is several miles.
Style
Some of the hippest bikes today are being built by Electra Bikes. They have cruisers that are pimped out with some of the coolest features like leather grips, tassels, and big comfy seats. And who wouldn’t like a bike model name like “Boney Finger”, “Ratrod”, or “Hellbilly”. But Electra’s “Townie” models are more suited to commuting.
If you’re in the market for cruiser but can’t afford the high prices of Electra, you should also consider Nirve. If you have a wad of cash burning a hole in your pocket then check out The Ride by Ellsworth.
Comfort
If comfort is important then you should weigh several factors. How upright is the ride? Does the fork have a shock absorber? What’s the butt/seat ratio (if your butt is huge, make sure the seat matches your girth)?
Many manufacturers are beginning to build some of their bikes with the crankshaft mounted more forward than your traditional bikes. The advantage of this configuration is that it puts your body in a more upright position so you’re not hunched over as far. This makes for a more comfortable riding position as well as putting your head higher above the ground which helps you see things better. The main disadvantage of being this upright is that your body acts as more of a sail in windy conditions.
The more common way to make you more upright is to sweep the handlebars back towards the rider. There are more of bikes that use this approach to getting the rider upright. If you care about comfort then you may want to consider how upright you feel on the bike so think about how much pressure is on your hands when you test ride bikes.
Another factor in comfort is shock absorption. There are usually two areas where shock absorbers will be found; in the front fork and in the seat post. Shock absorbers help smooth out the bumps along the way but nothing can completely eliminate them. The tradeoff of shock absorbers in the fork is that it can make the ride feel “mushy” and you may feel like you lose power climbing hills. But you’re just trying to get to work here, not win a race. If it doesn’t cost much more, get the shock absorber.
Don’t forget about the seat. Sure you can easily replace your seat later. But why not get a bike that already has a comfortable seat. Most bikes that are geared towards commuters have fairly wide soft seat so that’s usually not an issue. If you’re looking a bike with a tiny hard seat then chances are it’s not meant for commuting.
Stopping and Going
Don’t buy a bike without brakes. OK, maybe I could be more specific. The truth is, most bikes have pretty darn good brakes on them these days. But the best brakes in terms of pure stopping power in all conditions are disc brakes. The main advantage of disc brakes is that they aren’t affected by rain like pad brakes are. It’s not a deal-breaker, but if all else is equal, including the price, take the bike with the disc brakes.
When it comes to “going”, most bikes these days come with 21 or 24 gears. But how many people actually use anything besides the middle ring on the front sprocket. If you’re a middle-sprocket rider and you’re not commuting on the hills of San Francisco, then give serious consideration to a 7 or 8-speed model.
The advantages to having a 7 or 8-speed are lower maintenance (less moving parts), and it also allows you to have a chain-guard on the front. For commuters, a chain guard is a nice feature because it means you don’t have to worry about your trouser leg getting caught in the chain.
The 7-speeds tend to be your traditional external-hub shifters with the chain derailer doohickey (that’s the official term). However, many newer bikes are now being shipped with 8-speed internal shifters. The internal shifters are a very nice feature on a commuter bike because they (a) tend to be low maintenance because the lubrication is all self-contained and (b) you can shift while stopped. You’ll really appreciate being able to shift at a stop after having to stop quickly to avoid running over a suicidal prairie dog.
Extras
There are several other extras you’ll probably want to consider when shopping for a commuter bike.
Fenders are a must for those days when you get caught by an unexpected rain storm. Fenders that come stock tend to be a better fit for a bike. Look to make sure the fender coverage is good for the low side on the front wheel as well as most of the back tire.
Lights are a must for commuting in the cooler and darker days of the year. That doesn’t mean your new bike has to come with lights installed but it can be a nice feature. Many commuter bikes come with a light powered by the front hub which is nice if you don’t like to worry about batteries. But be sure to ask how the back light is powered. When you’re stopped at a traffic light, the hub-powered lights go out but some bikes have rear lights that will stay on in the back.
Racks and baskets are a nice feature to add if you like to cart lots of stuff back and forth. Sometimes these features will come stock but usually you’ll find them as optional accessories.
Bells and odometers and tassels and kickstands… theses are a few of my favorite things. But they’re not deal breakers. I think the inclusion of these types of items can reflect well on a manufacturer though, so think about what other things you might want on your bike before you plunk down the plastic. Maybe you can get the store to throw in an odometer to close the deal.
Comments
Add a Comment
CancelYou must be logged in.
Click here to log in.I have a very old-school looking Electra beach cruiser and I love it. So comfortable! Great guide!
I love my Trek 7500FX bike and installed lights, rack and large saddle bags (I can fit a child or computer in each one).
I bought an Electra last year and love it. And I get tons of positive feedback, because it is really colorful. I went for a bike with gears, and it is worth it.
I still use my pink and purple huffy… It doesn’t have a basket, but it does have a matching pink and purple plastic baggie on the front of the handle bars.
I just bought a bike last weekend and now I wish I would have used your guide first. Hm, maybe I’ll take advantage of the 30 day money back guarantee.
What a perfect time for this guide, it’s finally starting to warm up and holy cow gas prices are ridiculous. I’ll definitely have to check out some of these stores.